2011/6/1 Enrico Tröger enrico.troeger@uvena.de:
On Tue, 31 May 2011 23:42:58 +0200, Enrico wrote:
One addition:
Between these two I much prefer the Vector template's layout because: (1) I think it looks cleaner and more professional; (2) useful links such as "Printable version" and the Search input box are clearly visible. The Doogie template has almost none of this, with the Search input box at the very bottom of the page.
(3) the top navigation tabs can only be changed/configured by editing a PHP file, it's not changeable in the wiki itself. The Vector template implements the sidebar as a normal wiki page and so it can be edited by anyone who is granted to (ACL) not only by the few guys who have access to the server's filesystem.
Regards, Enrico
Personally I'd consider this a big PLUS in favour of the Vector template. Requiring someone who might maintain the wiki's layout to have access to the web server's file system is surely a risk.
In short I really don't like the Doogie template because of the reasons I've mentioned above, also the fact that the colours used in the banner/header make it difficult to read, also too bold. The focus of a wiki should be its content, not a big banner at the top of the page that looks ugly (IMHO :) ).