On Mon, 15 Nov 2010 09:41:53 +1100% Lex Trotman elextr@gmail.com wrote:
On 15 November 2010 03:29, Eugene Arshinov earshinov@gmail.com wrote:
Some results after preliminary investigation:
On Sun, 14 Nov 2010 14:25:54 +0300% Eugene Arshinov earshinov@gmail.com wrote:
On Sun, 14 Nov 2010 22:02:31 +1100% Lex Trotman elextr@gmail.com wrote:
On 14 November 2010 21:37, Eugene Arshinov earshinov@gmail.com wrote:
On Sun, 14 Nov 2010 21:24:39 +1100% Lex Trotman elextr@gmail.com wrote:
On 14 November 2010 20:31, Eugene Arshinov earshinov@gmail.com wrote: > Hi. > > I don't know whether it was this change which caused this, > but after I updated recently to r5395 and turned on the > #define in document.c which controls using GIO file > monitor, each time I save a document (I only use local > filesystems) I get a dialog telling me the file was > changed. In debug output coming from > document.c:monitor_file_changed_cb() I see that CHANGE > notification is sent twice after a file is saved. Maybe > it's g_file_replace_contents() which cause this,
Possibly, g_file_replace_contents writes to the temp file and then renames the temp file to the old file, but why two??.
The interesting thing is why doesn't any change to the file trigger the monitor no matter how its written?? Why does it only happen for GIO IO??
I was not fully correct. There were 2 CHANGE notifications and 1 "unknown" notification between them. Here is the output I get after opening, changing and saving a file:
Geany-INFO: /tmp/temp.xml : XML (UTF-8) Geany-INFO: /tmp/temp.xml : XML (UTF-8) Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: CHANGED; status: IGNORE -> OK Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: UNKNOWN; status: OK -> OK Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: CHANGED; status: OK -> OK
Since what is called change here is actually last_change_hint, you could actually get it several times because its only "probably" the last change.
Yes, and it also means that the original implementation, which ignores exactly one hint callback receives, is wrong. The comments near the #define actually tell that GIO based file monitoring is not completely stable, but when I ran an older version of Geany (maybe rev. 5380) with the #define turned on, saving seemed to work fine. Though there is a high probability that I'm wrong because I used that version only for testing new patches (i.e., rarely). Anyway, seems that I need to find a version where saving began to "fail".
Okay, it still fails at r5380. The change is caused by g_file_replace_contents() which was introduced before than that.
The unknown could be move/rename delete or just plain change (probably *not* last??).
Note that with my patch the output is different from trunk, but things should be clear. I'll investigate the unknown notification a bit later today, maybe it is caused by the rename.
I'm not sure how g_file_monitor would report an atomic rename of a temp file over the file we are monitoring?? The directory entry is changed and the old inode and data deleted if this was the last hard link.
You would have to test it or look at the source.
Yes, there's a need for experiments.
r5395 Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: 1 previous file status: 2
Probably the change of atime, though I would have expected that to be an attribute change event.
Geany-Message: monitor_file_changed_cb: FILE_CHANGED Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: 3 previous file status: 0
Create when the rename is done, OK
Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: 1 previous file status: 0 Geany-Message: monitor_file_changed_cb: FILE_CHANGED
Thats another change of atime when the file descriptor is closed (on Unix its closed *after* the rename).
r5065 (before g_file_replace_contents()) Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: 0 previous file status: 2 Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: 1 previous file status: 2 Geany-Message: monitor_file_changed_cb: FILE_CHANGED
And with safe file saving (ie g_file_set_contents) it just gets:
Geany-INFO: monitor_file_changed_cb: event: 3 previous file status: 2
Because it only does the rename it doesn't do the other opens and closes.
Its not the Glib version, it happens for me on 2.24.1 as well.
The above looks to me like Glib is working properly, Geany just needs to learn to ignore changes of its own making better.
Your mtime patch looks sensible to me, since we really don't want to reload unless the content changed. We don't care about changes to metadata since we don't use it. Except I suggest:
changed = doc->priv->mtime < st.st_mtime;
be != instead of < in case someone restores an old version using a tool that also restores the mtime.
Agree, but then we also need to change a similar check in document_check_disk_status():
else if (doc->priv->mtime < st.st_mtime) { monitor_reload_file(doc); doc->priv->mtime = st.st_mtime; ret = TRUE; }
Best regards, Eugene.