2007/12/7, Enrico Tröger <enrico.troeger@uvena.de>:
On Thu, 6 Dec 2007 19:12:01 -0300, "Diego Jacobi"
<jacobidiego@gmail.com> wrote:
> "Was the main.c opened when starting Geany or was only the project
> loaded without any opened files?"
> The main.c was not open, i opened geany and i got a blank file and
> when clicking on open project, it ask me to close the existing one.
> So the project was open but not the
main.c
Geany has "only" a basic project support. What it can and what not is
described in the manual.
Yes, i see now, the build menu on geany is related to the file opened, not to the project.
I see that options on this menu change according to the programming language.
This can make things really easy for single file projects, and for large projects ones must use makefiles.
I perfectly agree with that.
> "Project name and executable filename are two
> different things."
> I was talking about a default appname. If the programmer choose to
> set one diferent, then he should be able to do it, but if i compile a
> main.c i get a main.exe, and not a projectname.exe. Then, setting a
> file to run can be done almost automatically checking if
> projectname.exe exists, if not, shows an open dialog.
If you compile or build a file, you compile or build a file. There is
no support to build a project or something line
this.Maybe one want
to write a plugin or patch for this. Otherwise, using Makefiles would
lead to the same result with much less work.
Seems like you dont understand me.
I wasn't talking about makefiles.
And i agree projects should use makefiles not projects files.
> About the GEANY_USE_WIN32_DIALOG. its nice to have the option. Seems
> like the project is very well driven.
> There says: "The default Windows file dialogs are missing some nice
> features like choosing a filetype or an encoding."
> Choosing filetype?, i always have a combobox to choose, but i think
> that is called filter. Which in this case is almost the same.
No, it is no the same. The filter only filters files according to the
chosen filetype. The filetype selection in the GTK dialog is meant to
set the filetype with which Geany should open the selected file(s)
instead of autodetecting the filetype.
I see what you say.
Any way, i have never get on the need to have a so uncommon coded file that i should exactly tell what is the encodding.
Cant the autodetection ask for the encodding if doesn't detect it?
> About encoding, most good text editors i have seen, tries to
> autodetect the encoding, and allows to change it with options on the
Geany does this too. But there are limitations in auto-detecting the
file encoding. Patches to improve are welcome but the shown encoding
list was requested by users to manually choose an encoding when opening
files.
> "Open Build->Set Includes and Arguments and then adjust the Execute
> field to the path to your python executable as necessary."
> The "Execute field" is disabled, but it executes well, i guess that
> is not calling python directly to run the script, geany executes it
> directly. But for compiling it fails.
The execute field is disabled when you have an opened project and have
set a Run command for the project.
> "How to do that? Doesn't the $PATH variable exist exactly for that
> reason?"
> I think that not all the users can have access to change the
> environment variables.
Why? AFAIK, the PATH environment variable can also be set as an user
without admin privileges. And it is just the common way.
> To ask the OS i think that will be needed to use some windows files,
> maybe rundll or maybe, the windows api, i can check for that if you
> want. :)
If you want to, do it ;-).
> "where did you set it? This is not a problem of Geany but of your
> setup and/or gcc. To avoid passing all this on the command line I
> suggest to use Makefiles."
>
> I didn't SET it. The GTK installer does. And gcc is installed by its
> installer so both are as they come.
> What do you mean with the problem is on my gcc setup. Should gcc
> always check on the includes environ?
I don't know whether gcc should check these, should Geany? Then you
need the same thing for linker includes. And it seems not be some
standard way. Build support in Geany is not meant to be a complex
support-everything system but just a basic way to easily compile and
build small files. For bigger, more complex projects or source code
files there is the possibility to execute the make command.
I tried to compile a single file gtked hello world to test geany as a build environment for gtk, and it fails. Why? becouse i have to put manually each include path on the gcc line, which are all already on the INCLUDES path on windows.
To compile a single filed hello world i have to make a makefile. I think that it should maybe the 5º or 6º step on the gtk lernning process, or any C lernning process.
Makefiles are not easy for people how recently try to learn programming, and also i think that for compiling a single filed hello world when all the includes and libs folders are already declared on the systems environment variables a makefile shouldn't be necesary.
Dont know how much dificult could be appending a %I to be replaced for as many include paths as are on the INCLUDE environ or a %L to libs.
It will make things easier for simple projects, and leave makefiles only for multifiled projects.
The process should be:
Read the INCLUDES environ.
Split with ";" (windows separator).
Append -I to each path.
Join the list of paths.
Replace %I for the join list of paths.
The same for libs.
It makes testing an api and lernning much more easy as there is no need to make a makefile.
Cheers.